Title card reading "Shared Power, Kindness That Lasts" on a soft peach background with a sun, trees and flowers, and a row of people of different ages, skin tones and abilities, including a person in a wheelchair, joined hand in hand.

Even Good Leaders Are Imperfect: Why Healthy Community Needs Shared Power

I have been thinking about something that is hard to say out loud. Many leaders who inspired people to live with more kindness also caused real harm. I feel sad when I think about it, because I want to trust the people who point us toward goodness. I feel hopeful too, because I believe we can learn from it.

Not all of these stories are the same

Martin Luther King Jr. had documented affairs. His case is not the same as the others below, and I want to be careful about that. Some further allegations about him are disputed, and the tapes that might settle them are sealed until 2027. I do not want to repeat anything that cannot be confirmed.

Jean Vanier founded L’Arche, which has made life better for people with disabilities all over the world. After his death, independent reviews found that he had manipulated at least 25 women into sexual relationships, using his role as a spiritual guide. None of the abuse involved people with disabilities. The communities he started continue their work, and they have chosen to face the truth.

Ravi Zacharias was a world-famous speaker. After his death, an independent investigation found sexual misconduct, spiritual abuse, and an allegation of rape. He could not respond to the findings. Mike Bickle, founder of the International House of Prayer in Kansas City, was found by an outside investigation to have harmed 17 women and girls over decades, while some leaders worked to suppress the reports.

Some groups that hold everything in common, such as the Bruderhof, have been described by former members and critics as places where leadership held too much power and young people were harmed. The Bruderhof has acknowledged mistakes and disputes some of the descriptions. Whatever the full truth is, it is one more reason to look at structure.

So does power corrupt?

Psychologist Dacher Keltner of UC Berkeley finds that people often rise to power through empathy and generosity, and then power can erode those very qualities. They tend to become less empathetic and more impulsive. That means the answer is not to find “pure” people. Even good people can change when no one can say no to them.

Investigators of these cases also found secrecy, followers who were afraid to ask questions, and spiritual language used to silence people. Psychologist Diane Langberg, who has worked with abuse survivors for decades, points out that leaders are often chosen for their gifts and charisma more than for their character shown over time. She also describes how a whole system can come to protect the mission instead of the people.

What we can do

I feel hopeful about structures that make it safe to be human:

  • Shared leadership, with women and men both leading, and terms that end.
  • No one person holding both money and spiritual guidance.
  • Outside people that anyone can go to directly.
  • A fair way to look into concerns, with an independent investigator for serious ones.
  • The freedom to ask questions, say no, and leave with dignity.
  • Choosing leaders for how they treat people over time, not for how well they speak.

Quakers have used listening-based decision-making for about 370 years. It includes a “clearness” process where a small group asks only honest questions and gives no advice. Nobody rules, and everybody is heard.

I believe kindness needs structure to last. The goal is not to distrust everyone. It is to build a place where the kindest people can stay kind, and where anyone who is hurting can be heard.

Written together with Claude, who helped with the research and drafting. The ideas, questions and heart behind it are Patricia’s.

Sources: Miller & Martin report on Ravi Zacharias (via Christianity Today and CNN); Firefly Independent Sexual Abuse Investigations report on IHOPKC (via Premier Christianity and WORLD); L’Arche commission reports on Jean Vanier; Dacher Keltner, The Power Paradox; Diane Langberg, Redeeming Power; Parker Palmer on the Clearness Committee.

Leave a Reply